GreenPan vs. Caraway: Which Cookware Collection is Better?

We find several cookware sets in the market, but are they all safe for our health and the environment? Only a few brands offer eco-friendly and non-toxic cookware. And in this article, we will feature two of them: GreenPan and Caraway.

Both brands are designed with sustainability and safety in mind. GreenPan and Caraway are innovative brands. They use safe, sustainable materials that have a lower environmental impact.

But these brands have more to offer, right?

Let’s compare their features and benefits! And you will decide which cookware can give you a practical cooking experience.

Introducing GreenPan: Company Information

caraway cookware vs greenpan

GreenPan has been in the industry longer than Caraway. It is a flagship brand of The Cookware Company. They introduced GreenPan to the market in 2007. The brand aims to create non-stick cookware free of PTFE and PFOA. A year after, they introduced Thermolon.

The company prides itself on sustainability. All their cookware collection are from upcycled steel and aluminum. GreenPan has over 10 non-stick collections. Each has different looks and constructions but uses Thermolon on its cooking surface.

Introducing Caraway: Company Information

green pan vs caraway

Caraway is an impressive startup brand. With the help of social media and influencers, they gained traction a few years into the business. But, the brand is only focused on one collection. Its cookware collection consists of a saucepan, frying pan, sauté pan, and Dutch oven.

The brand may not have specialty cookware, but it offers everything you need to cook most meals. Besides non-stick cookware, Caraway offers kitchen accessories.

GreenPan Caraway
Founded 2007 2018
Origin China China, India
Non-stick Collection 10+ 1
Stainless Steel Collection 1 0
Price range $$ to $$$ $$$
Material Aluminum, hard anodized, or stainless steel Aluminum
Cooking Surface Diamond-infused ceramic non-stick Ceramic non-stick
Oven-Safe Yes Yes
Induction-Compatible Yes Yes
Dishwasher-Safe Yes
(Except Lima Collection)
Pros Affordable
Natural non-stick material
Impressive heat conduction
Natural non-stick material
Cons Low oven-safe temperatures
Less durable

Both companies have started in different years, and offer unique cookware collections. But they have one similar mission: to offer eco-friendly and non-toxic cookware.

GreenPan and Caraway focus on the health and well-being of their consumers. They do this without neglecting their impact on the environment. You can choose any of these cookware brands, depending on which suits your cooking needs. What’s important is both brands give you safer cooking experiences.

Material Composition: GreenPan vs. Caraway

caraway versus greenpan

Both brands use non-stick ceramic materials on their cookware. And they take pride in using an eco-friendly alternative to traditional cookware materials. Their cookware is free from PTFE (Teflon), lead, and cadmium, so you do not have to worry about toxic chemicals leaching into your food.

Caraway has only one type of construction, heavy-gauge aluminum with non-stick ceramic coating. Its magnetic stainless steel plate on the bottom gives this brand a competitive edge. Making it ready for induction cooktops.

But, if you want a few more options, GreenPan offers 3 types of construction. These are stainless steel, anodized aluminum, and standard aluminum. Each construction material has different benefits and price points. Among the 3, standard aluminum is more affordable, with good heat conduction.

And what gives GreenPan a competitive edge is its Thermolon coating. It has the same features of a ceramic non-stick coating but is more durable and metal utensil-safe. GreenPan also boasts its magneto induction technology. An energy-efficient induction base that ensures all cookware works on all stovetops. Like Caraway, their collection helps save energy as you do not need high heat when cooking.

But, there are some major differences in the design of both brands.

Design: GreenPan vs. Caraway

caraway vs greenpan

GreenPan has a more traditional design, while Caraway has a modern aesthetic appeal.

The overall color scheme of GreenPan cookware is in dark shades. Only a few of their collection have light pastels. Handles are a crucial factor in cooking. Its collection has a comfortable grip and is in place for stability. Lids are in tempered glass or stainless steel, and some of its collections are stackable. With GreenPan, you can choose among its various designs and features that suit how you cook.

But, if you want to keep it simple, Caraway is the one. It only has one collection offered in different color schemes. The lid handles are parallel to the cooktop and have a shape inspired by the shape of the caraway seed.

Yet, both product designs capture the consumers.

Heat Conduction and Retention: GreenPan vs. Caraway

GreenPan vs. Caraway pan

Heat conduction and retention are two features essential for cookware.

It is easy to determine the heat conduction and retention of cookware. You just have to pour two cups of cold water into the cookware, place each on the burner, and turn it to high heat.

We tested this on Caraway and GreenPan, and cookware distributes heat evenly. You cannot see any cold spots on the pans. However, the pans have different heat retention ratings.

GreenPan can retain the heat even after 10 minutes, while Caraway has lost its heat. However, it is important to note that GreenPan has several collections. So the results might differ if you use another cookware with different construction.

Cleaning and Maintenance: GreenPan vs. Caraway

GreenPan and Caraway have similar guidelines for cleaning and maintenance. Both brands claim to be dishwasher safe, except for GreenPan’s Lima Collection.

But, even when it says its products are dishwasher safe, handwashing them is still better. Dishwashers may use abrasive cleaners that damage the non-stick coating.

Handwashing cookware is better. You can efficiently loosen and remove stubborn food residues. Always follow the care instructions of each brand. This help ensures the best performance and longevity of your cookware.

Price Difference: GreenPan vs. Caraway

GreenPan and Caraway

These brands are not budget buys; each has a justifiable price point that makes your money worth it.

Caraway positions itself as a higher-end, making its price tag not budget-friendly. But just like any other brand, it offers an exclusive and sustainable feature that will serve you longer. Although Caraway is pricier, it does not feel that bad if you think of its generous warranty policy.

Meanwhile, with the wide cookware collection of GreenPan, they range from 150 USD to 650 USD. You can choose from depending on your needs and budget. The fully-clad stainless steel collection of GreenPan has almost the same price as the aluminum cookware of Caraway. So, if you want to maximize your money’s worth, GreenPan is better.

Warranty: GreenPan vs. Caraway

Both brands offer a warranty.

Caraway only offers a 1-year warranty and replacement covering manufacturing defects. But, this applies only to United States purchases. This could be unfair to overseas customers.

Meanwhile, GreenPan offers a 2-year warranty for its ceramic non-stick coating. And a lifetime warranty for defects in materials and quality.

These warranty offers are already impressive for non-stick cookware.

FAQs about GreenPan and Caraway

caraway pan vs greenpan

Here are some common things home chefs want to know about GreenPan and Caraway cookware.

Are GreenPan and Caraway cookware oven-safe?

Yes, both brands have oven-safe cookware collections. GreenPan has a lower oven-safe temperature. It may depend on which of its collection. But, It can generally withstand temperatures ranging from 320 °F to 600 °F. Meanwhile, all Caraway cookware can withstand up to 500 °F.

Is it okay to use olive oil in seasoning GreenPan cookware?

It is not advisable to use olive oil in seasoning GreenPan cookware. It can leave a thin carbonized layer on your non-stick cookware. This can be challenging to scrub off and may damage the pan. A safer alternative in seasoning your cookware is coconut oil and butter.

What utensils can I use with GreenPan and Caraway cookware?

GreenPan claims their Thermolon Diamond Advanced ceramic non-stick coating can withstand metal utensils. But, it is always better to only use nylon, silicone, bamboo, or wood utensils on non-stick cookware. Metal utensils may scrape the coating.

Are GreenPan and Caraway cookware induction-compatible?

There may be a slight difference in this aspect. All Caraway cookware is compatible with induction stoves. Thanks to the magnetic stainless steel plate on its base.

Meanwhile, GreenPan has several induction-compatible cookware from its collections. So if you are eyeing GreenPan, confirm its compatibility with an induction cooktop.

When to replace your cookware?

Cookware can last up to 5 years. But, some have already damaged the non-stick properties after a few months. Hence, this solely depends on how well you take care of it. You will know if it is time to replace your cookware set if the pieces are warped, discolored, or scratched.

We recommend following the cleaning guidelines for each brand. In this way, you can avoid replacing your cookware more often.

GreenPan or Caraway: So Which Should You Buy?

We have talked so much about both brands. Your preference and cooking needs will dictate the right one for you. Both brands are excellent options for ceramic non-stick cookware. If you want a few options, GreenPan offers more variety in construction and design. Not to mention, its wide range of prices.

Leave a Comment